Celebrity Brand Strategy Sydney Sweeney's Second Novig Ad Mocks the Men Who Bet on Her Underwear Celebrity Spielberg Was Honored at MoMA. CHANEL Has Paid for This Every Year Since 2011. Celebrity Kayla Harrison Wins the Title. Her Sponsor Is Still Fighting Its Own Scandal. Celebrity Brand Strategy The Quranic Pendant Kareena Wore to Diwali Drew a Legal Notice Celebrity Johnny Depp Wins the Box Office for the First Time in Eight Years Celebrity Billy Evans Asked A24 to Pixelate His Nude Scene. He Calls the Film a Favorite. Entertainment Industry CMA Barred Two Country Veterans From Its 60th Anniversary Red Carpet, Then Reversed Celebrity Brand Strategy Avril Lavigne Announced Her Daughter With Baby Vans. No Deal Required. Celebrity Brand Strategy Sydney Sweeney's Second Novig Ad Mocks the Men Who Bet on Her Underwear Celebrity Spielberg Was Honored at MoMA. CHANEL Has Paid for This Every Year Since 2011. Celebrity Kayla Harrison Wins the Title. Her Sponsor Is Still Fighting Its Own Scandal. Celebrity Brand Strategy The Quranic Pendant Kareena Wore to Diwali Drew a Legal Notice Celebrity Johnny Depp Wins the Box Office for the First Time in Eight Years Celebrity Billy Evans Asked A24 to Pixelate His Nude Scene. He Calls the Film a Favorite. Entertainment Industry CMA Barred Two Country Veterans From Its 60th Anniversary Red Carpet, Then Reversed Celebrity Brand Strategy Avril Lavigne Announced Her Daughter With Baby Vans. No Deal Required.
Ad Watch News
The Backlash

Kelly Clarkson Wanted a $15,000 Singing Bird. The Shop Says Molly Was Never for Sale.

Her 'Pretty Woman' post hit 40 million views, the Brooklyn shop fired back with a bird named Molly and a five minute timeline, and she called them liars... now both sides are stuck in the same review war.

Kelly Clarkson singing into a microphone at the 2018 DoD Warrior Games opening ceremony
Kelly Clarkson performing at the 2018 DoD Warrior Games opening ceremony (DoD photo by Marc Piscotty, public domain, Wikimedia Commons). Duotone treatment by Ad Watch News.

The thing Kelly Clarkson wanted to buy in Brooklyn was a bird. Molly, a one of a kind singing and dancing automaton bolted to the wall of Art of Play on Atlantic Avenue, is the object behind the 'Pretty Woman' post that had passed 40 million views by Monday morning, per Salon, citing The New York Times.

The shop broke its silence on Instagram on Sunday. Clarkson visited 'yesterday' and asked about buying Molly, it said, but the bird 'is permanently attached to the wall and isn't for sale.' The store said it was 'equally welcome' to every customer and described being 'suddenly attacked by 8 million people' who had never set foot inside, as Today.com reported.

A second post added the timeline. Clarkson spent five minutes in the store, the shop said. Molly's maker, Seattle artist Bliss Kolb, would build a nearly identical twin for $15,000, and the staff explained that to her. They also offered a different singing bird automaton from a German clockmaking shop for about $2,000, which she 'did not stick around long enough to see,' per Today.com. The store said it had reached out to Clarkson privately to clear the air.

'So You're Not Only Rude, You're Also a Liar'

Clarkson did not take the olive branch. In a Sunday post she disputed the not for sale line and quoted the employee as telling her the bird was 'for sale but it costs 15,000 dollars so if you'd like me to find something comparable for you I can.' Then the line that reset the news cycle. 'So you're not only rude, you're also a liar.' She attached a photo of Molly with what appears to be a price tag, though Today.com could not confirm whether she took the photo or pulled an older image.

She added that she 'obviously' supports small businesses, 'but you don't get a free pass to treat people less than in your store,' and closed with 'It's not that hard to be kind,' per Today.com and Salon.

The original Saturday post is still the engine. From her verified X account: 'Just drove all the way to Brooklyn to check out this store I thought looked really rad and had a few things in mind to buy and literally was looked at as if I couldn't afford it and was told he could find something comparable for me. Wow, dude. You're an idiot and just lost a huge sale. But y'all should go check out Art of Play in Brooklyn if you enjoy being treated like Julia Roberts character in Pretty Woman.'

The Review War Nobody Can Win

Fans started leaving negative Google reviews the day the post went up, as Page Six reported. By Monday the shop's Yelp page was flooded with both one star and five star reviews, per Today.com, as Clarkson's critics and the store's defenders fought it out on a listing most of them had never used. Some commenters on the store's post said they had seen a price tag on Molly in person. Others called a celebrity targeting a small business 'tone deaf' over a $15,000 toy bird.

A $15,000 Bird Is the Whole Story

This is a site about advertising, so here is the advertising read. The price is doing the work on both sides. For Clarkson the number proves the snub. A Grammy winner with her own daytime show was sized up and steered toward 'something comparable,' and $15,000 is the receipt. For the store the same number is the defense. Nobody keeps a $15,000 mascot on the wall to flip it, and the staff say they offered a real twin at that price and a cheaper bird besides.

Both accounts can be true at once. A shop can have a tag on a display piece that is not meant to leave the building, and a customer can hear 'something comparable' as a brush off even when it was an honest upsell down. What turned a five minute misunderstanding into a national story is that Clarkson named the store first and the store answered with a timeline instead of an apology. Once the word liar is on the table, nobody can back down without losing.

Who Comes Out Ahead

Our honest read is the same as before, with the stakes raised. The post fades, the reviews stay. Art of Play's listing now carries a permanent scar in both directions, and the first page of results for its name tells a story about a bird instead of a magic theatre. That is durable damage done by proxy, by people who never bought a puzzle there.

But the shop also just got the one thing a 26 seat curiosity store cannot buy, which is a national audience that now knows Molly exists. Curiosity is literally the product. The private outreach to Clarkson is the right move. The public timeline that followed it is the risky one, because it reads as winning the argument rather than keeping the customer.

What to watch: whether Clarkson brings the bird to her show, whether Bliss Kolb sells a twin to anyone off the back of this, and whether Yelp and Google clean up the reviews or leave the scar.

Ad Watch News is an independent commentary site with no affiliation with Kelly Clarkson, Art of Play, Bliss Kolb, or any outlet mentioned here. We cover celebrity news and the business of attention.

AdvertisementReally Good Cookies advertisementDune Awakening advertisement

Sources & further reading

More news
Independent commentary. Ad Watch News is an independent commentary and news publication. It is not affiliated with, authorized by, endorsed by, or sponsored by any celebrity, brand, or company mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Coverage is editorial opinion and reporting on matters of public interest. See our editorial standards.