Victoria's Secret Gave Kylie Jenner the $50 Million Bra. Its Own Fans Said She Hadn't Earned It.
We read the top 500 comments under the show on Victoria's Secret's own YouTube channel. 52 objected to Kylie Jenner in the Fantasy Bra. Two cheered.
At a glance
- Earned, not bought
- Of the 63 top comments that mention Kylie Jenner or the bra, 52 object to her wearing it. Two approve.
- Bigger than ever
- The show has 35.5 million views in its first week on Victoria's Secret's channel. Last year's show has 46.0 million after a full year.
- A thin quarter
- The company told investors to expect $10 million to $20 million of operating income this quarter while it spends more on marketing.
Forty-five minutes and fifty seconds into the stream, a single white light opens at the top of the runway. Three seconds later Kylie Jenner walks out of it alone, in white feathered wings and the Fantasy Bra that Jacob & Co. says holds 4,410 diamonds and is worth $50 million.
The camera cuts to the crowd. Phones are up. It was Jenner's first Victoria's Secret runway, and the brand built its most expensive moment around her.
Underneath the video, on Victoria's Secret's own YouTube channel, the brand's most devoted viewers wrote a different review.
A diamond bra should be worn by a deserving angel. Someone who worked their way through it.
We pulled the 500 top-ranked comments on Oct. 26 and read every one that mentioned Jenner or the bra. Sixty-three did. Fifty-two objected to her wearing it, and together they carry about 64,750 likes. Two were positive. Neither had a single like.
The complaints say the same thing in different words. "The fantasy bra is earned; not something that can be bought." "Why was the fantasy bra given to Kylie and not Adriana, Alessandra, Rosie, or Candice?" And the shortest one: "Money talks and Kylie walks."
YouTube rounds its like counts and ranks "top" comments by its own formula, so this is the loudest part of the audience, not a poll of everyone who watched. But it is the part that sat through 57 minutes on the brand's own channel.
Why a comment section matters to this CEO
Hillary Super came to Victoria's Secret in September 2024 from Rihanna's Savage X Fenty, the rival that had taken share from it. Her turnaround leans on the show.
We are increasing our strategic marketing investment to expand our reach.
In the same filing, she promised "an even bigger and better Victoria's Secret Fashion Show," and the company guided to operating income of just $10 million to $20 million for the quarter the show falls in. The show is the marketing, and the margin for error is thin.
By the numbers, the show worked
The full stream had 35,453,382 views by Oct. 25, a week after it aired. Last year's show, streamed the same way, has 46,023,181 views after a full year. The livestream peaked at 3.64 million viewers, up about 33%, and the brand's own channel held 81.72% of all watch time, according to Streams Charts.
Wall Street didn't flinch either. The stock closed at $87.34 on the Friday before the show and $89.98 on the Monday after, up 3%. By Oct. 23 it was at $90.82. Nothing in that move proves the show caused it.
Google searches for the show, by our pull of Google Trends, peaked on show night and were down 96% four days later. The video kept collecting views anyway.
One caution on the headline number. The $50 million is Jacob & Co.'s own valuation of its diamonds, and the jeweler was the show's official partner. It is the jeweler's showcase, not a figure from Victoria's Secret's books.
Victoria's Secret has not publicly responded to the criticism.
The company reports the quarter in early December, around Dec. 3 by analysts' estimates. Investors will get the sales number then. The fans already left theirs, in the brand's own comment section.
Sources & further reading
- YouTube: The Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2026 (official stream; scene at 45:50, views as of Oct. 25)
- YouTube: 2025 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show (official stream, 46.0M views as of Oct. 26)
- Ad Watch News comment count: top 500 comments on the 2026 stream, pulled and read Oct. 26, 2026
- SEC: Victoria's Secret & Co. Q2 2026 earnings release (8-K, Sept. 3, 2026)
- Streams Charts: Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2026 viewership
- Bloomberg Law: Victoria's Secret nabs Rihanna brand CEO to lead turnaround (Aug. 2024)
- Forbes Australia: Kylie Jenner wears $50 million Jacob & Co. Fantasy Bra
- LA Mag: Highlights from the Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2026
- Yahoo Finance: VSXY daily closes, Oct. 16 to 23, 2026




